In the Ethiopian War the West Sides with a Terrorist Group

BY YONAS BIRU (PHD)

As Noah Smith, a Bloomberg Opinion columnist, took note, “the most-educated immigrant group in the U.S. isn’t East Asians. It’s Africans.” Ethiopians are among the African groups that are doing well. They occupy faculty positions in America’s flagship universities, including Harvard, Yale, Princeton, University of Pennsylvania, Stanford, Columbia, Cornell, among others. At some point there were four full professors as well as associate and assistant professors at Mayo Clinic, America’s number 1 ranked Medical School.

An Ethiopian immigrant, Joe Mamo, is building an iconic skyscraper in Tysons, Virginia, that will be “the tallest of any currently standing between Philadelphia and Charlotte” – 539 miles (867 km). And this is one of five high-rise buildings he has filed for permit to build, simultaneously. Yohannes Abraham, another Ethiopian American was the Executive Director of the Biden-Harris Transition, “overseeing preparation for the implementation of Biden-Harris policy and management priorities.”

Why, then, are Africans poor and often at war in their country, while peaceful and successful in the West? Simply put, the West’s intervention in African politics has distorted the political incentive structure and the constraint matrix, institutionalizing a power calculus in favor of terrorist political groups. The push from such a system explains the mass exodus of African elite more than the lure of economic opportunities in the west.

The problem emanates from a racist misconception that Africans cannot be held to high democratic standards. Having a stable system is good enough even if it does not meet democratic standards. Consequently, a stable system that is enforced through terror became the source of political legitimacy.

Here is how African politics is seduced with terrorism. Unscrupulous politicians use the barrel of the gun and the state’s security apparatus to take over or remain in power, invade the economic space to collect rent, and hold the people hostage for ransom as bargaining chips to milk financial aid from the West. Evidently, violence and poverty have become key elements of the political equation in the game theoretic sense. The calculus of political profiteering embedded within the geometry of the vicious cycle of violence and poverty is what brought the current war in Ethiopia, and, sadly, what is sustaining the aftermath.

The war at issue is between the Tigray People’s Liberation Front (TPLF) that was running the Tigray regional state, and the Ethiopian Federal government. Understanding this war is understanding how the West’s intervention in African politics has distorted the political incentive structure and the constraint matrix, institutionalizing a power calculus that favors authoritarian leaders who use acts of terrorism to establish a predatory political and economic governance.

TPLF was established in 1975 by hardened communists who fancied themselves as followers and later heirs of Enver Hoxha, the supreme leader of Albanian Communism. Soon after TPLF was established, it was listed as a terrorist organization in a US-based global terrorist database, namely Terrorism Research and Analysis Consortium (TRAC).

After 16 years of guerrilla warfare, the terrorist establishment took over the government, in 1991. Once in power, the US removed them from the global terrorist list. To remain off the terrorist list all they had to do was to pretend to run elections every five years with no intention of losing power or conceding seats – often winning 100% of all national and regional elections.

The 2005 general elections proved an anomaly in TPLF’s uncontested reign. The incident is the window through which Kjetil Tronvoll, a professor of peace and conflict studies at Bjørknes University College, showed us a glimpse of TPLF’s sheer terror. He exposed TPLF’s threat of mass murder and sustained poverty that brought both the people of Ethiopia and Western nations to their knees.

In 2005, the unthinkable happened. The TPLF-led government, the Ethiopian People’s Revolutionary Democratic Front (EPRDF), lost the election. The government delayed the announcement of the results, triggering the people to take the streets in protest. As a result, “security forces and police killed at least 36 people….5,000 people were arrested and detained,” Tronvoll documented.

According to Reuters, the government refused to concede defeat and, in the aftermath, additional 200 civilians were killed, 800 wounded, and 30,000 arrested. As Tronvoll noted, in a unanimous disapproval of the government’s terrorist actions, “the donor group tried to play tough.” The group decided to withhold international aid until those who won the election were allowed to take their rightful seats in the Parliament and those who ordered the police to shoot to kill peaceful protesters were held accountable.

The then Prime Minster Meles shrugged them off and told them “pack up and go home if they were not interested in helping the country to develop.” As Tronvoll put it succinctly, in commiseration of the poor people whom TPLF holds as hostage, the donor community and decided to “stay quiescent on internal human rights violations and lack of democracy.”

In the next election cycle, the opposition pleaded with the donor nations to use their leverage to observe the elections. “Fourteen foreign embassies generally washed their hands of the whole exercise for fear of provoking the government” Tronvoll lamented.

The UN defines terrorism as: “criminal acts, including against civilians, committed with the intent to cause death or serious bodily injury, or taking of hostages, with the purpose to provoke a state of terror in the general public or in a group of persons or particular persons, intimidate a population or compel a government or an international organization to do or to abstain from doing any act.” This is how TPLF governed Ethiopia for 27 years.

It needs to be remembered, during its reign as the head of government, TPLF was not a rent-seeking force in the traditional sense of the term where politicians extort kickback from the business community. It was an armed looting enterprise. The Party was running business for profit, curving out all lucrative sectors for a near monopolistic control and enforcing its privileged position through terror.

Speaking of TPLF’s armed rent-seeking endeavor, Martin Plaut, BBC World Service Africa editor, flagged: “TPLF’s tight rein on political freedoms and human rights, while giving privileged access to resources to the prime minister’s core constituency in Tigray.”

There is no question that the Tigray region benefited during the TPLF’s era. This has been documented in World Bank reports in 2017 and 2020. Another legacy of TPLF was illicit funds transfer out of the country. According to IMF data, as presented on the Brookings Institute website, “the top four emitters of illicit flows—South Africa, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Ethiopia, and Nigeria—emit over 50 percent of total illicit financial flows from sub-Saharan Africa.”

Two numbers tell TPLF’s looting enterprise, as described in the Forbes Magazine: “The amount of American financial aid received by Ethiopia’s government since it took power: $30 billion”; and “The amount stolen by Ethiopia’s leaders since it took power: $30 billion.”

TPLF’s motive in launching the current war, according to the US government, was “to overthrow the Prime Minister and return to the type of privilege they had enjoyed within the Ethiopian State for the last 27 years”.

Contexts and pretexts matter. Let us retreat a bit to 2018 and look at what transpired since TPLF lost its firm grip on the leavers of power, after a nationwide uprising. It left behind over a million forcefully displaced people, a nation gripped with political anxiety and tittering at the verge of a civil war fueled by ethnically charged and restive unemployed youths. To top it off, the nation was mired in economic despair.

Dr. Abiy Ahmed was selected as Prime Minister. At the time, his challenge was approximated by an unlucky pilot pushed into the cockpit of a crippled plane in flight occupied by unruly travelers and asked to land it safely.

Across the conservative-liberal spectrum, international observers cheered his stewardship. The conservative Fox News reported about “sweeping changes that seemed unthinkable just weeks ago have been announced almost daily.” Five months after Prime Minister Ahmed took office, the liberal leaning CNN praised him for “electrifying Ethiopia with a dizzying array of reforms credited by many with saving the country from civil war.”

Others also piled on accolades for the Prime Minister’s “path for prosperity” whose success “could ignite economic change through emulation equivalent to South Korea’s influence on Asia in the 1970s” In October 2019, at the age of 42, the Prime Minister won the Nobel Prize for Peace for, among others, ushering in “important reforms that give many citizens hope for a better life and a brighter future.” The US-based Freedom House flagged Ethiopia as one of the five “most encouraging examples of democratic progress over the past two years” in the world.

What the Ethiopian populace and the rest of the world hailed as a promissory note for Ethiopia’s peace, security and prosperity, TPLF saw as a declaration of proclamation to end its political dominance and economic rent-seeking empire. It vehemently objected every aspect of the reform from releasing political prisoners to liberalizing the economy.

Yearning to regain its heydays of armed looting, TPLF leaders retreated to Mekele, the capital of Tigray, and began building a militia force that ultimately reached 250,000. Once in Mekele, they constantly objected the Prime Minister’s agenda, looking for a fight.

As the BBC reported, they declared the Prime Minister “an illegitimate leader, because his mandate ran out when he postponed elections due to coronavirus.” The fact is that it was the National Election Board of Ethiopia (NEBE – a constitutionally empowered autonomous government agency) that decided to postpone the national and regional election because of Covid-19. The federal government and all regional states barring TPLF agreed to be governed by the decision of the NEBE.

On November 3, TPLF launched a surprise attack against the Ethiopian National Defense Force (ENDF). The former US Secretary of State, Michael Pompeo made this clear, stating: “The United States is deeply concerned by reports that the Tigray People’s Liberation Front carried out attacks on ENDF bases in Ethiopia’s Tigray region on November 3. We are saddened by the tragic loss of life.”

What Mr. Pompeo did not disclose is that the ENDF was attacked from within by officers of Tigrayan origin, who slaughtered their fellow soldiers who hailed from other parts of the country in their sleep. Having invaded the ENDF in Tigray, next on TPLF to-do list was invading the neighboring Amhara regional state to take over two ENDF garrisons stationed there with the aim of strengthening their fire power, before marching to Addis Ababa to overthrow the Prime Minister’s administration.

After his futile plan failed, the head of TPLF called upon the US and European capitals to pressure Prime Minister Abiy to negotiate a power sharing settlement. The alternative, he said, will be bloodshed, hunger that will affect over 6 million people in the Tigray regional state and a destabilized Horn of Africa. As noted in the Washington Post, the US Secretary of State for Africa, Tibor Nagy, is on the record, stating TPLF is motivated by a desire “to internationalize the conflict in Tigray.”

TPLF’s terrorist actions worked well for its architects. It did not take long for Western governments to start exerting pressure on Prime Minister Ahmed to negotiate with the terrorist group. Ethiopia was confronted with two choices: Allowing TPLF to extort political concession to stop the reform through war or reject its reckless gambit and launch a law enforcement campaign. The government chose the latter.

A recent Washington Post editorial portrayed Ethiopia’s law enforcement campaign as “an invasion” against the Tigray regional state. It further characterized it as having “all the earmarks of Ethiopia’s previous dictators.” At best, this arrogance fueled by utter ignorance of the pretext of the war. At worse, it is a repulsive racist policy that uses a different standard for Africa.

It merits recalling that when the mob invaded the US Capitol Building, on January 6, the Washington Post was singing a different tune. It never questioned why 25,000 army forces were brought in rather than the police. It did not talk about mediating and reconciling with the insurgents. Rather its call was to hunt them down and bring them to justice.

TPLF is singularly responsible for the war. This does not mean the Ethiopian government gets a free hand in the way it conducted the law enforcement campaign. Its delay in allowing unfettered access to international agencies to investigate atrocities committed during the war played in the hands of TPLF heired American and European lobbyists.

And then there is the 800-pound gorilla in the room: the Eritrean involvement in the war. Many including the US government have concluded Eritrea was involved. There are two issues. First is the intervention of Eritrean forces. I found it amusing that TPLF is complaining about it. It is to be remembered that TPLF took power in Addis Ababa in 1991 with Eritrean forces fighting alongside it.

Second, more recently TPLF tried all it could to get Eritrea on its side. Daniel Berhane, TPLF’s senior advisor posted on his Twitter handle: “To my Eritrean brothers and sisters. There is a war in Tigray. Make no mistake, it is a war on all of us. Whoever wants to kill Tigrayans would have you as his next target. We’d better stand together.”

The involvement of Eritrean army in the war is an issue that the Ethiopian government should be fully transparent. It can explain or even defend its decision to involve Eritrea. The second issue is the widely held accusations that atrocities including widespread rapes and mass murders are committed by Ethiopian and Eritrean forces. This has to be investigated both by the Ethiopian Human Rights Commission and by international organizations. The investigation must include the Mai Kadra mass massacre and the November 3 war crime of murdering Ethiopian solders and generals in their sleep.

The government needs to understand TPLF’s survival strategy remains creating a risk for mass starvation and regional instability for political gains. Those who believe that TPLF cares for the people of Tigray should read Martin Plaut’s 2010 expose. During the 1984/85 famine that claimed over a million lives (most of them in Tigray) TPLF was selling sacks of grains mixed with sacks of sand to international NGOs who were buying grains for food aid.

Currently, TPLF is all but a totally destroyed entity. Its effort to resuscitate itself draws its energy from the oxygen it gets from international intervention. The international community’s policy must be two pronged. First, it must reject TPLF’s futile effort to resuscitate itself with the help of the international community. Second, it must exert maximum pressure against the Ethiopian government to open and maintain unfettered access to international investigation and bring those who perpetrated war crimes and crime against humanity to justice, if the allegations are confirmed by credible and independent investigators. Anything more is a violation of Ethiopia’s sovereignty. Anything less is a dereliction of international moral obligation.

The Ethiopian herald March 3/2021

Recommended For You

106 Comments to “In the Ethiopian War the West Sides with a Terrorist Group”

  1. Wow Thanks for this publish i find it hard to obtain good quality tips out there when it comes to this subject material thank for the post site

  2. Wow Thanks for this blog post i find it hard to realize decent important information out there when it comes to this blog posts thank for the write-up site

  3. Wow Thanks for this thread i find it hard to realize exceptional important information out there when it comes to this blog posts thank for the content site

  4. Wow Thanks for this article i find it hard to identify great important info out there when it comes to this content appreciate for the thread website

  5. Wow Thanks for this thread i find it hard to find smart ideas out there when it comes to this subject matter appreciate for the information site

  6. Wow Thanks for this content i find it hard to discover really good important info out there when it comes to this subject material appreciate for the thread site

  7. Wow Thanks for this article i find it hard to stumble on awesome guidance out there when it comes to this content thank for the information site

  8. Wow Thanks for this guide i find it hard to acquire good quality particulars out there when it comes to this topic thank for the publish website

  9. Wow Thanks for this content i find it hard to search for decent details out there when it comes to this topic appreciate for the site site

  10. The music video for “Vocal77” was directed by vocal77pro. It is a tribute to rave culture and electronic music. It consists of a compilation of various amateur slot vocal77 recorded

  11. The VOCAL 100 club is our monthly lottery which raises money for carer support and pays out half of the fund in cash prizes. This

  12. VOCAL77 hadir untuk melayani para pecinta togel di seluruh Indonesia. VOCAL77 hanya menyelenggarakan Lottery dari negara-negara yang menyediakan hasil lottery yang legal dan sah seperti SINGAPORE49, SINGAPORE45, HONGKONG dan SYDNEY. VOCAL77 telah beroperasi sejak tahun 2015 dengan menyelenggarakan pembukaan account Taruhan Togel yang dilakukan secara online. Kami berkomitmen untuk memberikan pelayanan terbaik dan memuaskan kepada seluruh member kami dengan di dukung oleh staff kami yang profesional dan handal

  13. The best dubs go beyond the basics of the format, and make those vocal77 loops sound as if they absolutely need to be vocal77 repeated.

  14. Cyberchase is an animated science fantasy children’s television series that airs on PBS Kids. The series centers around three children from Earth: Jackie, Matt and Inez, who are brought into Cyberspace, a digital universe, in order to protect it from the villainous Hacker (Christopher Lloyd).[4] They are able to foil Hacker’s schemes by means of problem-solving skills in conjunction with basic math, environmental science and wellness. In Cyberspace, they meet Digit (Gilbert Gottfried for the first 13 seasons, Ron Pardo since season 14), a “cybird” who helps them on their missions.[5]

  15. Resend OTP in: 30 seconds Crypto-eligible customers will be able to access funds in kind if they have an open or approved Coinbase account. The condition applies to crypto-eligible customers who did not withdraw crypto from BlockFi’s web platform by April 28 or did not verify their identity by May 10. After the arrest of Bankman-Fried, the Securities and Exchange Commission, along with the U.S. Congress, planned to discuss regulations of the cryptocurrency industry. If a cryptocurrency exchange files bankruptcy, there is no backup — unlike U.S. banks, where the government insures the funds up to certain limits. Experience seamless interchangeability in the Xapo Bank app, swapping between Bitcoin and US Dollars with ease wherever you are.Your USD deposits are safeguarded up to the USD equivalent of EUR 100,000 by the Gibraltar Deposit Guarantee scheme while our BTC reserves— one of the largest in the world — offer unparalleled protection from Bitcoin losses4.
    http://thermocare.kr/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=361958
    After locating the nearest Bitcoin ATM to your location through the CoinTime ATM website, here are the next steps you should follow to transact: Bitcoin ATM USA (678) 435-9604 support@bitcoindepot 2870 Peachtree Rd #327Atlanta, Georgia, 30305 The Bitcoin ATM at New Holland located at Shell Gas Station is placed at the front of the store on the right from the main entrance door, next to the traditional ATM.The Bitcoin ATM at Shell Gas Station is available to the public 7 days a week, 6am to 10pm, and transactions are simple and instant, the entire process of purchasing Bitcoin takes only a couple of minutes.You can buy bitcoin for cash or sell bitcoin for cash using this Bitcoin ATM. Watch a step-by-step video on how to buy and sell cryptocurrency at a CoinFlip by Olliv ATM. All Bitcoin ATMs with opening hours, directions, photos, number of resources and online offline status can be found on the subpage Bitcoin ATMs – Map. We announce the opening of new locations on social media and as news in the Blog section. You can also suggest the opening of a new unit (or suggest something else) by leaving feedback on GoogleMaps. To do so, go to the Feedback page.

  16. Pragmatic Play has a lot of expertise in Bingo and casino table games, but it also offers an excellent range of modern slot games to its customers. With great aesthetics throughout and an impressive selection of bonus features, Pragmatic slots score highly among players. Almost all of our top rated free online slots are also suitable for mobile play, whether that be with iPhone, iPad or Android devices. Setting up on your mobile couldn’t be simpler, as these games are developed with mobile users in mind. You can choose to download a free slots app, or if you prefer you can access a mobile casino in your browser and play as you would do on a desktop computer. With that in mind, why not set aside a little bit of time today to play some of the many different types of free spins awarding slots? You have the no risk free play option, so feel free to spin games free of charge and enjoy the free spins bonus game free spins. With free spin slot games, you will then be able to shortlist a rage of slots you have enjoyed playing and can give them some real money action when you are in a position to do just that!
    http://www.fshrental.com/yc5/bbs/board.php?bo_table=free&wr_id=49820
    The best online casino bonuses are available at BetMGM, Caesars Palace, DraftKings Casino, FanDuel Casino, Golden Nugget and Borgata. This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase, a SQL command or malformed data. Learn what to expect from a no deposit casino bonus and which online casinos in India offer the best no deposit bonus out there. CasinoAlpha specialists do not recommend this bonus if you’re a new player with a tight budget. If you have a higher spending limit on your gambling budget and want to get the 125 free spins, first create your account, get the bonus, and then, after you complete the wagering add the money. Moreover, you can also get the first deposit bonus if you deposit the minimum indicated sum and extend your odds with a match deposit of 200%.

  17. Wow Thanks for this thread i find it hard to stumble on good quality related information out there when it comes to this content thank for the thread website

  18. Wow Thanks for this information i find it hard to get beneficial particulars out there when it comes to this content appreciate for the content site

  19. إن الخطط التأجيرية التي تطمح إليها كبرى الشركات والتي تتناسب مع احتياجاتها في السوق لتطوير أعمالها عن طريق تخفيض المصاريف و الإنفاق هي عدم تملك السيارات ، والتي تؤدي إلى تكبد الشركات خسائر من تبعات تملك السيارات على المدى الطويل من مصاريف ( صيانة ، حوادث ، تأمين، سيارات ايجار بديلة، وقت مستهدر و متابعة ). تقدم شركة ذيب خدمات تأجير للجهات الحكومية والخاصة قصير الأجل وطويل الأجل وتوفر سيارات تناسب كبار السن وذوي الاحتياجات الخاصة ( المعاقين ) بالإضافة إلى خدمة عبر الحدود للسفر بالسيارة خارج المملكة ودعونا لا ننس خدمة المساعدة في حالات الحوادث والصيانة وتأجير سيارات ليموزين وبيع السيارات المستعملة وغيرها من الخدمات.
    https://touch-wiki.win/index.php?title=ايجار_سيارة_سبارك
    إذا تم اختصار زيارتك في المدينة لأي سبب كان، وكنت ترغب في إعادة سيارة الإيجار في تاريخ سابق للتاريخ المذكور على قسيمة الإيجار، فيمكنك ذلك بإرجاع السيارة إلى نفس الموقع المحدد في القسيمة، ولكن؛ في هذه الحالة، لا ولا المورد مسؤول عن رد أي مبلغ للمستأجر.VIP Cars تبلغ تكلفة استئجار السيارات القياسية في روما وسطياً 611 ﷼ في اليوم. +971 50 755 5509   | ٦- :استثناء الموظفين الموظفون العاملون في شركة ار بي ام وأفراد عائلاتهم غير مؤهلين للمشاركة في هذا العرض

  20. Sign up *–>* Disclaimer: We do not encourage any form of gambling or gaming where it is prohibited. Users should verify the legality of online gambling in their jurisdiction before proceeding. This website is not responsible for any legal consequences that may arise from individuals not adhering to applicable laws. The information provided is accurate as of the date of publishing. However, as details may change over time, readers might receive different offer if the details have expired. Nevertheless, we try to ensure our offers are up to date at all times. People who decide to use the company’s mobile applications will have to complete special steps to get it on their devices. The app for Android is not available on Google Play, whereas the one for iOS is accessible after completing a few specific steps. Both processes will take a couple of minutes, which means people can start using them in no time.
    http://www.gospelhochzeit.de/2021/06/23/kak-popolnitj-schet-v-pokerdom-minimaljnij-depozit-v-poker/
    For a smooth update process, ensure your device is connected to a stable Wi-Fi network and has sufficient battery life. It’s advisable to update the app as soon as a new version is available to benefit from the latest improvements and security features. If you encounter any issues during the update, restarting your device can often resolve these problems. A platform like 1xBet which uses the latest safety and data protection measures can be considered as a trustworthy betting site. Download 1xBet (latest version): an app for Android, IOS and Windows is available. Keen players and those, who want to make the bets online, don’t need to have access to 1x bet site now. All it takes is to download 1xbet application for your smartphone. Your pocket screen equipped with 1xbet app becomes a perfect tool in any player’s hands, significantly improving his user experience in sport betting.

  21. slot5000 slot5000 slot5000
    Today, while I was at work, my sister stole my iPad and tested to see if
    it can survive a twenty five foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple ipad is
    now broken and she has 83 views. I know this is
    completely off topic but I had to share it with someone!

  22. Depositing Time The search filter for casino software developers adds an extra touch to the Casinoly user experience. I was able to use a drop down list to filter the games by my favorite developers, although it was also possible to just type the developer’s name in the search bar and get a list of games by that developer. Furthermore, Innovate Change promotes safe gambling practices, ensuring players gamble within their means. By staying updated on the latest industry developments, Innovate Change provides recommendations based on current information. They also prioritize secure transactions and reliable customer support, enhancing player satisfaction. Innovate Change builds trust and confidence by being open about how it evaluates games and looks after players. While well-known titles such as Gonzo’s Quest and Fortune Reels are available, there is a clear intention on the part of Casinoly to place a greater emphasis on games that correspond to the Ancient Greek theme of the site, such as Gates of Olympus and Titan’s Rising, which are also available.
    https://directory-2020.com/listings361739/new-slots-games-free-online
    Absolutely! Anything we develop aligning fintech is designed to be scalable and adaptable to accommodate your business growth. Whether you are expanding your operations, adding new products or services, or entering new markets, our solutions can evolve with your changing needs. In short, fintech software development companies are instrumental in transforming the financial industry through their innovative software solutions. By leveraging technology, data analytics, and artificial intelligence, they enhance the efficiency, accessibility, and security of financial services, ultimately shaping the future of finance. We provide Software Development & Digital Marketing Services for restaurants, cafes, and other businesses in Food services. Tell us the financial software solution idea you have in mind, and our tech team will come up with the right offer for you. We will design a clear roadmap that covers all aspects of the process, from ideation and planning to implementation and maintenance. Our extensive experience in fintech development makes us the perfect partner for you. Whether you want a web-based digital banking solution, an enterprise desktop application, or a mobile application, we deliver on time and on budget. We are equipped with the experience of successfully delivering online banking portals, customer communications management platforms, document processing solutions, fraud monitoring and detection systems, and risk management systems.

  23. No matter if some one searches for his essential thing, therefore he/she needs to be available that in detail, thus that thing is maintained
    over here.

  24. A fascinating discussion is worth comment. I think that you should write more on this issue, it might not be a taboo subject but
    usually folks don’t speak about these subjects.
    To the next! Cheers!!

  25. Paragraph writing is also a excitement, if you be acquainted
    with after that you can write if not it is complicated to write.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *